13th Pureland Patriarch Yin Guang
(He is considered the emanation of Mahasthamaprapta Bodhisattva or Vajrapani)
Question : I have been vegetarian and reciting Amitabha’s name for many years. It is said that Buddhist practitioners are watched over by Buddhas of the ten directions and three times. The devas, nāgas, eight classes of beings and mighty Dharma protectors constantly accompany and guard them. Negative karma from past lives is gradually purified, even if there is past enmity, they cannot cause harm. This is what the Buddhist scriptures teach and is by no means untrue.
However, in March, I unexpectedly received a death notice from relatives in Shanghai. It concerned Mrs Zhang, a very devout Buddhist. She had been vegetarian for over twenty years and often went to the monastery to listen to the Dharma. Whenever she met others, she would urge them to recite Amitabha’s name and be vegetarian. She was extremely compassionate and devoted to virtuous deeds.
Who would have expected that, one day, while delivering vegetarian food to a fellow practitioner, she was walking along the road when she was suddenly hit by a car. Her body was taken away by the police and her family only learned of the incident three days later and went to retrieve her corpse for burial.
When I heard this, I was so shocked and, to this day, unable to resolve my doubts. Those within the Buddhist community who heard of it were also deeply unsettled. Therefore, I respectfully write to the Venerable Elder for guidance. Why did she have such a tragic death? Did she manage to attain rebirth in Sukhavati? Please explain this clearly so that everyone may feel at ease and continue reciting Amitabha’s name with confidence. I would be endlessly grateful.
Reply from Venerable Yin Guang:
From your letter, it seems that you, Sir, have yet to attain a genuine understanding of Dharma principles. From beginningless time, the negative karma created by us ordinary beings is immeasurable. The Avataṃsaka Sūtra says that if negative karma could take form, all of space in the ten directions would not suffice to contain it.
One must understand that when the practitioner’s cultivation is truly sincere without pretence or hypocrisy, negative karma can be turned around and purified. Heavy karma can be lightened while karma that would ripen later (in a more severe form) will ripen earlier (in a lighter form). Ordinary people can only see the immediate good or bad circumstances; they cannot comprehend how cause-and-effect from past and future lives truly unfold.
This elderly lady practiced diligently for many years yet died tragically. It may be that through this suffering she extinguished the karmic retribution of being reborn in the three lower realms and thus attained rebirth in a higher realm. If she had genuine faith and aspirations, she might be reborn in Sukhavati. However, since I lack the clairvoyance that knows others’ mind, I do not dare to confirm if she has taken birth in Sukhavati or not.
What can be stated with certainty is this: virtue inevitably brings positive results while non-virtue inevitably brings suffering. If one creates virtue yet receives a seemingly bad outcome, know that this is the fruition of non-virtue from the past and not the result of present good deeds.
You and others, upon seeing this elderly woman meet such an end, gave rise to the doubt that “virtue brings no blessings, therefore it is not worth practicing virtue,” thus becoming alarmed and confused. How does such understanding differ from that of people who have not listened to the Buddhadharma at all?
If one deeply believes in the Buddha’s words, one would not give rise to such fear and doubt because of this one incident. Causes and effects overlap endlessly—sometimes this cause has yet to bear fruit while the result from another cause ripens first.
It is like planting rice. What is planted earlier is harvested earlier. Or like debt collection, the stronger creditor demands repayment first. In ancient times, there were people who performed virtue throughout their lives who died miserably, thereby extinguishing past karmic debts. In their next life, they attained wealth, nobility, and honor.
For example, during the Song dynasty, a monk at Ashoka’s monastery wished to build a relic hall. Knowing that Prince Yi had great power, he went to solicit donations from the Prince, but the Prince gave very little. The monk was very angry and severed his own arm with an axe in front of the relic hall, bleeding to death.
At around the same time, the prince’s wife gave birth to a son who cried incessantly. When the nurse carried him around, he would stop crying only when brought before a hanging image of the relic pagoda. Once away from the picture, he began crying again. The image was taken down and constantly shown to him, thereafter the child stopped crying completely.
The prince found this strange and sent someone to Ashoka’s monastery to make inquiries. It was discovered that on the very day the child was born, the monk had severed his arm and died from loss of blood. The prince then sponsored the construction of the entire relic hall. When the boy reached the age of twenty, Emperor Ningzong died without an heir, the boy was adopted and ascended the throne, reigning for forty-one years as Emperor Lizong of the Song dynasty.
The monk’s death was a tragic one. The infant cried ceaselessly but calmed down at the sight of the relic image. Who is to say whether this child was the rebirth of the monk who died so grievously after severing his arm?
This account is in the Records of Ashoka Mountain. I personally read it in the 21st year of the Guangxu reign when I paid homage to the relics for more than a week.
Those who understand Buddhist principles are unshaken no matter what circumstances they encounter, they will never doubt the law of cause and effect nor doubt the Buddha’s words. Those who do not understand cling rigidly to worldly views, they are unaware of the complexity of karma and give rise to deluded doubts. This is entirely due to the absence of right view.
Those who recite Amitabha’s name receive the blessings of the Three Jewels and protection of the eight classes of beings such as devas and nagas, this is an established principle and certainly not false. One who does not understand that purification makes heavy karma ripen earlier in a much lighter form naturally forms such doubts.
In the past, in the Western Regions, there was the Vinaya master Śīlabhadra whose virtue was so immense that his fame pervaded India. Due to past karma, he suffered from a very terrible illness with suffering so cruel that he could not bear it and wished to end his life.
Then, the three Bodhisattvas Manjushri, Samantabhadra, and Avalokiteśvara appeared and said to him: “In past times, you often took birth as a king who harmed beings. This karma would throw you into the lower realms for a long time, but because you propagate the Buddhadharma in this life, this small suffering in the human realm is used to purify the karma of immense suffering in the hells for many eons. You should accept and bear with it. A monk Xuanzang of the Tang Dynasty will come to India to learn the Dharma from you for three years.”
Upon hearing this, Śīlabhadra endured his suffering and repented sincerely, over time he recovered. Three years later, when Xuanzang arrived, Śīlabhadra instructed his disciples to describe the suffering of his illness. Those recounting it choked with tears, showing how extreme the pain had been.
If one does not understand causes from past lives, people might say that Śīlabhadra was not a truly accomplished monk; they might question why such a great practitioner could still suffer so terribly, doubts about the efficacy of Buddhadharma might arise.
What you know is limited, thus when you encounter something unusual, you immediately fear and doubt. Those without sufficient good roots may lose their faith or regress on the Dharma path.
Likewise, when good circumstances arise for evildoers, people again give rise to wrong views. They do not know that everything arises from previous causes and that purified karma can ripen earlier in a lighter form or, conversely, (constantly accumulated) karma can ripen later and in a much heavier form. The interaction of causes and conditions is very intricate, it does not work in a neat and obvious way.