Reciting Amitabha is not a simple practice

Venerable Elder Guangqing

Reciting Amitabha is not a simple practice. You need to thoroughly let go and cast aside all internal and external distractions, single-mindedly chanting Amitabha —only then can you gain attainments.

Recite Amitabha’s powerful name clearly and hear your recitation clearly without having a single thread of doubt. Distracting thoughts dissolve and you will definitely enter a state of one-pointed concentration.

If you believe my words, recite Amitabha genuinely. Whether walking, stationery, sitting or reclining, do not be apart from this thought of Amitabha. Even in your dreams, you can sustain the (mental) recitation of Amitabha and not be distracted by the sense perceptions.

Once you reach this stage, your mind will drop all attachments and be unconfused. When your practice reaches maturity, Sukhavati will naturally manifest before you. You must not be careless about this!

If the mind is sincere, wondrous fragrances and bright lights will appear when reciting Amitabha. Even if you are dwelling in the mountains, with only three blades of grass as an incense, an extraordinary fragrance will emit from the incense. Buddhas and Bodhisattva pervade all of space, they are not only present in the monastery. If the mind is sincere, you connect to Amitabha.

All Dharma practices come down to this mind. Our daily practice is essentially to cultivate this mind. If this mind possesses meditative stability, it will be like pure and still water. Such water reflects all images without exception. Therefore, when our minds are very pure, we naturally perceive the true nature of all things.

Our practice of reciting Amitabha is meant to cultivate this mind until it is as pure and tranquil as water. If the mind is scattered and impure, it is like muddy water. There are many non-virtuous thoughts, the mind judges what is good and bad, what is tasty or not, what is fragrant or foul-smelling; it becoming attached to "forms, sounds, smells, tastes, tactile sensations and mental objects."

When the recitation of Amitabha reaches a point where this mind is clear, bright and free from impurities, one will naturally cease to cling to the "five aggregates." In this way, the six sense organs will no longer be affected by the six sense objects; afflictions will be severed, and the five aggregates will be realized as empty.

You will naturally transcend all suffering and difficulty, manifest the luminous wisdom of your self-nature, and penetrate the profound and subtle Dharma.

The emphasis in Amitabha recitation is on “mental focus" and "pure dedication". One sustains the recitation day and night without interruption or distraction. Reciting with the mouth, listening with the ears and being mindful with the mind is the way to make the effort.

Gradually and naturally, you will reach the state where there is no distinction between day and night, one recites single-mindedly without distractions. Through reciting Amitabha, one attains concentration; from concentration, wisdom opens and one is certain to accomplish results.

Knowing time of death beforehand

Venerable Elder Guangqing

If there are many thoughts when chanting Amitabha, the method is to ignore these thoughts.  Just recite Amitabha. If you try to get rid of distracting thoughts, that is adding one more thought or affliction on top of what you already have. Once you have recited Amitabha sufficiently, thoughts will be reduced on their own.  Also, your worldly desires will decrease and it will be easier to reach single-minded focus…

When reciting Amitabha, every thought is never apart from Amitabha.  You recite clearly and hear each recitation clearly. Every syllable is clearly recited.  Your mind is placed on the sound of Amitabha that you hear through your ears while your mouth is reciting. In this way, the Amitabha chant engages your mind fully. You let go of everything else and suspend your attention on this sound, this is how you reach a single-pointed mind…

There are many methods of chanting Amitabha.  When you have not reached a certain level, you often waver between methods.  Sometimes you feel this method makes you concentrate better, later you feel another method is better.  This is because our mind lacks stability. Sometimes we think “this is good, or is that better?”

This comparison of better or worse is from our discriminating mind. Before reaching a certain stage, one has such fluctuations and mind cannot settle down.  Actually, every method is good. They are only an expression of our self-nature.  If you let go, that is your self-nature.  If you use a certain method, that is also your self-nature.  Therefore, it is not necessary to generate such attachments when you practice…

When you are dying, do not hope for or try to see visions of Buddhas or Bodhisattvas.  Whatever you seek is false or unreliable.  Without any expectation of seeing anything, simply recite Amitabha with a pure mind; whatever arises from your mind naturally is then true.  

Don’t speak of gaining anything, if there is something to gain, one has not yet reached.  When reciting Amitabha, recite until there is only this one thought of Amitabha left in your mind without any other distracting thoughts.  Then you will know your time of death beforehand.  If there are other thoughts, they will obscure you and you will not know the time of death beforehand.

No control in the bardo (Story)

An account by the Terton Jatson Nyingpo about his mother

At the same time I heard that my mother was dying, so I went to her; she died with her head pillowed in my lap. I performed the ejection of consciousness (phowa) and recited dedications and aspirations. I placed a liberation-through-wearing yantra on her body and placed samaya substances in her mouth. I cremated her myself. For seven weeks I dedicated virtue to her. 

During those weeks I repeatedly met her in dreams; I would say to her, "Meditate on Chenrezig. Repeat the Mani mantra. Let your mind rest naturally, without alteration."  During the first week she replied, "That is not easy; I don't trust myself. My awareness is vague and indistinct; it has no stability. I have seen no happiness in this world, only suffering. My son, do whatever you can to help me!"

During the second week I dreamed that she was as real as when alive. I taught her Dharma to clarify the bardo state as before, and she replied, "Oh father! Oh mother! I had no idea the bardo was going to be like this! All the people who don't practice Dharma during their lives are foolish, foolish! Guru! Three jewels! When I look up I see penetrating light rays and hear empty sound. When I look down I am terrified and hear wails of agony. I have no control over what I do now. Please keep trying to help me!"

I offered a lot of butter lamps, enlisted the help of the Three Jewels, and made burnt offerings including samaya substances; my mother was reborn as an animal.

Having witnessed what she had gone through I realized how much good I was doing myself by practicing Dharma. I wrote many songs then out of sadness. I repeatedly sponsored tea service for all those staying at softwater spring; distributed grain, salt, and butter, and gave them whatever ragged clothing I had to give; gave barley meal and other food to starving villagers; protected the area from blights and hail; caused rainfall; prevented sickness and epidemics; protected the area from predators; gave medicine to the sick; gave yantras for eating and wearing to those who mistook their own thoughts to be demons; gave authorizations and blessings; and banished obstructors. With the best intentions, I really did whatever I could to help everyone in the area.

(Note: Jatson Nyingpo was a famous treasure revealer who revealed the Konchok Chidu cycle.  He did confined retreat for 17 years and was the Guru to the 10th Karmapa amongst other great masters.)

Be careful about criticizing others

HH Jigme Phuntsok Rinpoche

If we created the karma of abandoning Dharma, there will be no chance for liberation.  This is something we have to be very careful about.  What does the karma of abandoning Dharma include?  It includes slandering or criticizing Bodhisattvas.  We do not know at all where the Bodhisattvas are, therefore we should behave carefully towards anyone. There are Bodhisattvas amongst the monastics and laypeople.  We will not know if even an animal is a Bodhisattva.

(Note: According to the sutras, the karma of abandoning Dharma prevents one from taking birth in Sukhavati. One must quickly confess and purify it if one has committed such karmas.)

Going to Sukhavati despite heavy killing karma

Kathok Rigzin Chenpo Rinpoche

There was an old man in Gansu named Langde. He was a war hero of his tribe, stayed in Mula village, his descendants are still around today. 

In his youth, during the Mongol wars and tribal conflicts, he killed many people and created heavy negative karma. In his later years, he constantly repented. He recited an enormous number of Amitabha mantra and name over a long period of time and also recited Dampa Deshek’s phowa prayer.

In the 1950s, he was imprisoned for many years. After being released, he passed away in the Luqi County in Gansu. He said to the person who received him upon his release from prison, “I won’t be able to return to my home but I have done a great deal of Amitabha practice. My negative karma has been purified and I am about to go to Sukhavati.” Joyfully, he sat on the roadside reciting Dampa Deshek’s phowa prayer and passed away with total freedom and peace.

The same thing happened to my maternal grandfather. During chaotic times, he also killed many people and created very heavy karma. Later, he too recited Amitabha’s mantra and practiced phowa, attaining rebirth in Sukhavati.

In short, this Dharma method has immense blessings and power. Many ordinary people have practiced it and attained rebirth in Sukhavati. Although they do not have any attainment in the generation or completion stages, they possess sincere faith and a mind of repentance, through which even very grave karma can be purified.

When doing this practice, think often of Amitabha’s qualities and powers. In this world, people most easily resonate with practices related to the Lotus Family among the Five Buddha Families — such as Avalokiteshvara, Amitabha, and Guru Rinpoche. For beings with strong desire, the deities of the Lotus Family are especially effective. The requirements for practice is also easy—as long as you have faith in Amitabha, you can practice.

Of course, unwavering, stable faith, loving-kindness and compassion are in themselves not easy qualities to have. Perseverance is not easy either. The two people mentioned above did not attain their accomplishment in an easy manner. I once asked others about how they practiced.

Although they had created very heavy killing karma, they were also loyal, courageous and trustworthy people. Later on, for more than ten years, they diligently repented and did the practice of Amitabha. Langde did a walking pilgrimage from Gansu to Lhasa. For three years he avoided idle talk and devoted himself solely to Amitabha practice. My grandfather was the same. For over a decade he practiced continuously. Every day, he recited Amitabha’s mantra and practiced the phowa prayer without talking unnecessarily.

Thus, their accomplishment of Sukhavati did not come easily without substantial causes. The main point is to have determination and make a firm resolve. With this determined mindset, there is no problem, you too can definitely accomplish it.

~~

Dampa Desheg's Phowa Prayer 

DE WA CHEN DU JANG SEM LO DRO’I NYING

Bodhisattva of Sukhavati, Lodro Nying

KHA WA CHEN DU CHO JE KA THOG PA

Lord of Dharma in the snowy land of Tibet, the one from Kathog

MA JON DE SHEG TSHE PAG MED PA ZHE

Who will manifest as Protector Sugata Amitayus in future

DRAG PAY TSA GYUD LA MAR SOL WA DEB

I pray to the renowned Root and Lineage Gurus 

DE WA CHAN DU KYE WAR THUG JE ZUNG

Hold us with your compassion so that we may take rebirth in Sukhavati

(Note: Dampa Deshek is the founder of the Nyingma Kathok lineage and said to be an emanation of Amitabha himself.)

Entering the Wrong Door

An interesting story by Chan Master Nan Huaijin

When I was studying Buddhism in China, I had a friend who was meditating one day and something extraordinary happened…

In Chengdu, there was a monastery that we, the students from the Central Military Academy, knew well. The academy was located at Chengdu’s North Parade Ground and Manjushri Monastery, a large monastic complex, was just nearby.

(Note: Master Nan served in the military when he was young.)

After classes, the students would sometimes sneak out. Even as officers, we occasionally slipped out to relax. I lived at Mt Wudan near the North Parade Ground, it was only a short distance to the monastery—just a turn and you’d be there. The monastery was huge, with hundreds of monks, and I was very familiar with every one of them. Whenever I went, they would call out, “Come over here!” I could visit any monk’s room.

So our group of Buddhists often gathered there. It was really a matter of merit—how else could one have such a conducive environment for learning Dharma? I went to the monastery frequently. When the bugle sounded, I could run back to the academy in time without any problem, therefore I never neglected my duties.

Behind the monastery was a vast garden with towering nanmu trees. They were incredibly tall—if you tilted your head up while wearing a cap, the cap might fall off! The trees were beautifully arranged, and their leaves seemed to embody kindness and humility. Each leaf grew in such a way that when it approached another leaf, it naturally gave way, leaving a small gap between them. It was indescribably wonderful—a genuine practice place of Bodhisattvas, no way else to describe it!

There was also a pig enclosure behind the monastery. People might think that the monks were raising pigs to eat, but that wasn’t the case. These were “liberation pigs” (animals released to be spared from slaughter). A monk in charge of growing vegetables—whom we regarded as a living Arhat—took care of them. He worked tirelessly, filthy all day from labor.  Two monks grew food to offer to hundreds of monks. This monk carried manure and did all the dirty work—truly an Arhat or Bodhisattva!

He fed leftover food from the kitchen to a pair of pigs, one male and one female. Under the protection of two monks, they reproduced continuously, and soon there were many piglets. We would joke with him, “Gardener monk! How about giving a couple to our military academy?”

He would reply, “No! You soldiers would just kill and eat them!” And he kept the gate tightly shut, not even letting us look at the pigs. We said that we just wanted to play with them and not eat them.  The monk only relaxed after we left. He was afraid we would kill the pigs and eat them.

So, as I was saying, one of our friends practiced Chan meditation. One day, while sitting in meditation, he suddenly felt himself slip into a state of unconsciousness for a while. In this state, he saw a familiar elderly woman appear before him, saying, “Come, come, I’ll treat you to tea.”

In Sichuan, people love tea. After drinking the tea, she led him to a place of incredible beauty—clear mountains, flowing water, birds singing, flowers fragrant—everything was perfect. The old woman said, “There’s an even better place. Follow me!”

She led him somewhere that felt both familiar and unfamiliar. Eventually, they arrived at a grand mansion which was high-class and magnificent, with large red gates and bronze rings that clanged when struck.  (In Chengdu there were such old mansions that belonged to extremely wealthy families of high position and great power.)

She said, “Come in.” He hesitated: “This is someone’s home. I don’t even know them—why are you bringing me in?” “It doesn’t matter,” she said.

Inside, it was splendid with corridors and gardens like something out of the novel “Dream of the Red Chamber”. Then she led him to a private chamber and told him, “Go in and take a look.”

He protested, “This is someone’s bedroom! How can I just go in?” She replied, “If you want to go, go. If not, I can’t force you.”  He felt annoyed—why was she so improper, bringing him here? But as he turned to leave, curiosity got the better of him. He opened the window and peeked inside. Inside, a woman was giving birth.

He was startled and disgusted: “What bad luck! Why did you bring me here to see this?” He immediately turned and ran away.  At that moment, he woke up from meditation, covered in cold sweat.

He thought, “I’ve never fallen asleep during meditation before. This shouldn’t have happened. Even if it wasn’t an out-of-body experience, it was still a kind of demonic state, like a dream.  It was a state of unclarity and ignorance. Something’s wrong.”

He went to Manjushri Monastery and wandered to the back garden where the vegetable-growing monk was. The monk said, “Ah! Our old sow has just given birth!”

“How many?” 

“Six. One was stillborn.”

“Where?”

“Over there—go take a look.”

When he went to look, he saw a red paper sign posted at the pigpen’s entrance. It was exactly the same sign he had seen in his “dream” with the same handwriting by the monk. It said, “Do not enter—sow is giving birth.”

Except, in his dream, he saw “Do not enter—mother is giving birth.”

He was shocked. “My goodness! If I had gone in, I would have become one of those piglets!”

Out of the six piglets, one had been born dead. He believed that was because his “bardo body” had not entered it. This brief lapse into sleep had almost led him there.

Just think it as me babbling a fairytale! (Audience laughed.)

This story shows that when beings are reborn in the animal realm, they don’t feel like they’ve become animals. They still feel like they are humans. In the desire realm, craving and desire are extremely strong. This force of desire is irresistible—stronger than magnetism. Once it pulls you, you are drawn in instantly. Space and time pose no difficulty or obstruction.

That is how frightening attachment and desire truly are.

 

The challenge of the final moment

Dharma Master Jingjie

The eighth consciousness (alaya-consciousness) is usually inactive, however, it begins to manifest as we are dying. This vast storehouse (of your deepest consciousness) that holds immeasurable afflictions and karmic forces accumulated over countless eons only appears at two times: at the time of dying and at the moment of rebirth.

When the eighth consciousness appears, it does not “hold back”. It does two things: inwardly, it produces afflictive thoughts in your mind; outwardly, it manifests as karmic appearances.

Some people are perfectly fine in ordinary times but become confused and afflicted at the moment of death. This is not really their fault because the eighth consciousness is inactive during daily life. But, it is activated when we are dying and manifests the things we have been most deeply attached to over countless lifetimes.

These thoughts repeatedly arise and you clutch to them, afflictions and deluded thoughts surface from the depths of the eighth consciousness at the moment of death. Also, karma (within our eighth consciousness) that is near maturation will manifest a kind of bardo body which misleads us.

Therefore, a dying person is said to face both inner and external disturbances.

If you have not prepared well during ordinary times, many people who recite Amitabha well in daily life fail to pass this critical hurdle at the moment of death because it is an entirely different situation.

Everyone should understand that mindfulness of Amitabha in daily life and mindfulness of Amitabha at the moment of death are two completely different situations, because the states are very different.

In daily life, you are dealing with only a small portion of life’s suffering. At death, you are facing a total upheaval of your life. Naturally, these are not the same.

Many pureland practitioners mistakenly think that reciting Amitabha in daily life is exactly the same as when dying. They just go along practicing but when the final moment comes, they cannot get through it.

Therefore, we must prepare ourselves well. No matter what happens at the moment of death, the key is that you must develop the inner mental strength to overcome obstacles on your own.

Good quality life depends on a quiet mind

Phurpa Tashi Rinpoche

We must learn how to rest our minds no matter where we are.  If a person has a constantly restless mind, this becomes a habit.  If we allow this to become our habit, our minds are unable to settle down whenever we do Dharma practice. 

There are two types of people: those who are impatient and those who are relatively slower in their reactions.  It is much better to be slower. Slow down your thoughts and physical actions, then your mind can slowly become tranquil.  If you can do this, no matter where you are, you will feel happiness and peace in your mind.

When one’s mind is restless, even eating delicious and expensive food, or wearing beautiful and luxurious clothes will not make a lot of difference to you.  Time passes in a flash due to your lack of mindfulness. 

The happy person is able to experience every single moment fully.  This is only possible when one’s mind is settled and quiet.  If I were to ask a person whose mind is very restless and distracted, “How did you pass your day yesterday or the day before?” this person is usually unable to recollect how he spent his time, because his life is spent in a lack of awareness, with a restless and distracted mind. 

On the other hand, if you are able to savour and experience every passing minute and moment, being very present, it means that your mind is clear and in a state of purity.

When a person’s mind is restless, time passes very fast without being noticed.  “Oh! It’s afternoon already!” “Oh! It’s night time already!”  (audience laughs.)  Therefore, one must learn to relax the mind, don’t simply allow your mind to wander. Otherwise, you do not experience much during your entire life.

I recall my days in the retreat center (in Yarchen monastery) with great fondness.  We were not allowed to go anywhere beyond the yard. During the 100 days of winter, time seemed to stretch on infinitely.  Each day seemed to last a very, very long time.  We had a lot of time and there was the feeling of having infinite time.  Every single part of the day seemed to stretch on endlessly. 

But presently, I feel like I am skipping over blocks of time unknowingly. This is due to the restless mind — a mind that is unable to quieten down. 

The days I spent in the retreat center were filled with an incredible happiness.  Even making a meal seemed so leisurely and time moved slowly, unlike nowadays when we seem to be missing entire blocks of time because mind is not allowed to rest.

A good quality life depends on a quiet and centered mind.  A restless mind will definitely reduce the quality of our lives. Even if you fill your life with quality enjoyments like good food and beautiful clothing, you will not be able to enjoy the experience fully. It is almost like putting beautiful clothes on an unfeeling corpse. Someone who lacks the sense of smell will not really appreciate good food.

Basically, our present state is quite similar to not having these senses.  This is owing to our restless mind.  So, we must learn to settle into the flow of life. When mind is quiet and rested, life becomes very enjoyable.  When mind is restless, you always feel something is lacking, something is left undone. You are constantly wandering around somewhere. This kind of life feels so meaningless and shallow. 

For a practitioner, quieting the mind is essential and of greatest help to the practice. Therefore, applying such mindfulness to our life is very helpful to our practice. We need to subdue or tame the mind, therefore this is very important!

Some people say that a rich life depends on the quality and not on the length of the life.  (Rinpoche chuckles) Yet, who truly manages to experience their life fully? They think that luxuries of good food and good clothes bring a premium, top-tier life. But these are not the factors that bring about quality of life at all!

If you gave these wonderful food and clothes to a dead person, would it make a difference to them?  Although we have the sensory functions of sight, taste and touch, we can’t truly utilize them to truly experience our lives because our minds are restless and distracted.  

Our lives become quite sad and pathetic because of this.  We are like walking robots or corpses simply passing the remaining time of our life.

Today, we live for tomorrow. Tomorrow, we live for the next day. Everyone says, “Live in the present.” Yet, who truly does?  A restless and distracted person will never be able to live in the present. We are always planning. “Where should we go tomorrow?” “What should we do tomorrow?”  We are living in the future, not in the present.  This is the sign of being restless.  

I am also an impatient person who eats very quickly. My doctor advised me to eat slower to help my digestion. Therefore, the quality of my life is quite lousy too…  Okay, I have said a lot about this. That’s all for now, I still have recitations to do.

Lifetime of cultivation vs karma

Dharma Master Jingjie

When I was studying at the Buddhist College, I was present at the passing of two senior Dharma masters. One was a Chan (Zen) practitioner. He had received the lineage transmission from Master Miaoguo, and his meditative power was formidable.

He told us that in the early days of his Chan training, they would meditate for twelve hours a day. Of course, the essence of Chan is not just in cultivating meditative concentration. Within that stillness, one must practice the Perfection of Wisdom by contemplating the emptiness of the self and phenomena, investigating what is your original face (ultimate nature). 

One could see that this master’s wisdom regarding emptiness was very strong. His lifestyle was very simple, he accepted any conditions that happened to him with detachment. 

Later, he had cancer and was dying. Naturally, he did not recite the Amitabha's name, nor did he wish for us to do so for him. When he was dying, it was understandable that he experienced pain. He initially asked his disciples to help him into a seated posture. But after sitting for a while, it was too much to bear and he had to lie down. As he lay there, I looked at his expression; he was enduring the pain and his brow was slightly furrowed.

Compared to the karmic forces accumulated over beginningless eons, we say that the cultivation of a single lifetime might still run into problems. A Chan practitioner does not usually take refuge in Amitabha’s name, therefore, they are entirely at the mercy of their karma.

The other senior Dharma master was a Pureland practitioner who passed away a year after the Chan master. We were also by his side to assist in the supportive recitation of Amitabha’s name.

A pureland practitioner is certainly different. This elderly monk also had cancer, and he felt pain at the end of his life—you could see it in his facial expression. However, when we chanted beside him to assist his passing, his mouth started chanting along with us.  This activated his object of refuge. 

After reciting for a while, something incredible happened. As his mouth kept moving with us, his expression—which originally looked pained—gradually became at ease. His complexion turned from pale to rosy. After a while, he gestured with his hand to indicate that he wanted to lie in the Auspicious Reclining Position. We helped him into that position and continued reciting.  After a short while, he passed away peacefully in the midst of chants of Amitabha.

I witnessed both of these masters' passings. From the perspective of self-power, I believe the Chan master’s qualities of Discipline (Shila), Concentration, and Wisdom surpassed those of the Pureland master.  We could see that as we all lived together. But why was the Pureland master able to pass on so well? It is because in his life there was an additional force of Buddha’s blessings and Buddha’s blessings are inconceivable.

Amitabha’s mind is equal to all beings, like the sun shining everywhere on earth. But for the Buddha’s blessings to illuminate you, it cannot be one-sided. If you have no mind of taking refuge in the Buddha and do not recollect or think of him, how can there be a response?

I believe the reason this Pureland master was able to transcend his suffering was largely due to the Buddha's power.  This is what is referred to by "passing on with mindfulness".

At the moment of death, our only recourse is Faith, Aspiration and Amitabha’s name — relying on Other-power. The Buddha’s compassionate vows are infallible.  Amitabha’s retinue will appear before one to provide comfort and guidance. Therefore, one remains unconfused and achieves rebirth in Sukhavati with ease.

Be generous to yourself too

A dialogue between a practitioner and a teacher

~~

A practitioner said that she has been suffering from anemia for a long time. Despite taking iron supplements, the results have not been very effective.  She consulted a teacher.

Teacher:

From the divination, your body seems fine. The cause of anemia is that you are experiencing a certain karma ripening.

I wonder if you had habits in the past of being overly frugal over food and other things.  From the divination, it looks like this habit is deeply embedded in you over a long time such that your body and life is overtaken by it.

Now, even if your body takes in food, it cannot absorb the nutrition well because your mindset does not allow you to truly benefit from the food.

First, arrange some pujas. But you must make more Bodhichitta aspirations (to purify the similar sufferings of beings through your own suffering)... The more you formulate such (expansive and altruistic) thoughts and aspirations in your mind, the more it purifies this habitual force in your mind, and the fetters will correspondingly weaken.

When your mind no longer restrains your body out of stinginess, your body will begin to recover…

Practitioner:

Thank you Master. I have always thought that being reluctant to spend on oneself is a good habit.  My mother taught me this and she is like that too. I will pay attention to making stronger aspirations in future.

In the first place I was already reluctant to spend on myself. After entering Buddhism, I believed that spending on oneself was depleting my merits, so I became even stricter with myself.

Before, I thought that anemia was due to being vegetarian. But nutritional supplements haven’t helped, so I assumed it was due to karma. Now I allow myself to consume and spend more but I worry that it will increase my greed.

I still don’t quite understand. I would like to ask: isn’t being thrifty about spending on oneself considered conserving merits? Why does it create an obstacle instead? …

Teacher:

When the mindset of stinginess or thriftiness is reinforced over and over again over a long time, it is not just about the body receiving insufficient nourishment but one may also experience in advance the suffering of the hungry ghost realms.

The underlying mental factor of such reluctance to spend is actually stinginess, it is not really about conserving merits. The more you reinforce this stinginess, the more solidified it becomes.

Some people, whether they are wealthy or not, are willing to eat and dress well. When they habituate to this generous mindset over time, they will not have a difficult life in this lifetime and in future lives, things will only get better and better. The mindset of willingness to give out or spend is in itself an open heart and life will improve over time due to this habitual tendency or karmic imprint.

To determine whether one is truly conserving merits, one must examine one’s inner motivation. If you use the concept of “conserving merits” to restrict your body and mind, you may conserve some merits, but the merits will also stop growing. As you use up your merits, they only decrease, and as they decrease, you cling on even more tightly to conserving them and your life enters an increasingly narrow path.

If you live your life with an open heart, being willing to eat and spend on yourself as necessary, merits will also increase in an unseen way.

What is called “merit” is essentially the state of your mind. It is not some invisible and limited thing. The more expansive your mind becomes, the more limitless your merits.

Practitioner:

I am willing to spend money on pujas, virtuous deeds, or learning Dharma, it might be because I know these actions generate merit. But I do not have equanimity since I only spend intentionally with a purpose in mind. I find it hard to understand my own thinking too. My practice is also stuck here, perhaps this is another form of greed.

Teacher:

We know that making offerings and doing virtuous deeds are good. When we act on this understanding and make offerings, the merit generated can be very great.

However, at the level of motivation, if our intention carries a sense of calculative purpose, the merit can easily be exhausted. When virtuous actions are done with the motivation of Bodhicitta, that merit will continue to grow and increase.

In samsara, what is constantly reinforced and solidified in the mind is our habitual tendencies—such as greed, anger, stinginess, and other afflictions. As one goes through life after life, the dominant habits become increasingly solidified. These primary habits are what binds us within samsara. Therefore, practice must be directed towards dissolving one’s main habitual tendencies.

It is not the case that once you become willing to eat and dress well, your mind will immediately turn greedy—it does not happen that quickly. As long as the tendency of stinginess has not dissolved, your mind will continue to be governed by stinginess. Only after stinginess has been dissolved entirely, will other weaker afflictions arise to take the lead.

For example, if someone has a very strong tendency toward arrogance and they work very hard at doing virtuous deeds and making offerings, the merit generated can be very great. However, if their primary affliction—arrogance—has not been effectively countered, then what determines the direction of their present and future lives will still be that arrogance. 

Upheavals in human history

Chan Master Nan Huai Jin

Throughout human history, the upheavals any nation goes through should not be solely blamed on a few leaders. Most unrest and chaos arise because the general atmosphere of society is already problematic, that is to say, it is caused by the degeneration of human values and morals as a whole. 

Although a few powerful individuals can sometimes alter the course of history, there are times when even they are powerless. When a situation becomes irreversible, later generations describe it with the term “unavoidable calamity”. This implies that the suffering of such turmoil is the result of the collective karma of all humans or people of a specific region. Such tectonic shifts in fortune are not something a small group of people can hope to reverse.

~~

An impending catastrophe or the ripening of collective karma for a nation can only be turned around if everyone works together to correct their actions and mindset.  It cannot be resolved by some miracle. Each person must take responsibility for their own karma.  Buddhists understand this principle and begin by cultivating their body, mind and conduct, making it purer and more virtuous.

We cannot do wrong and simply ask the Buddhas or Bodhisattvas for forgiveness.  If everyone behaved this way, where's the understanding of cause-and-effect? Cause-and-effect is incredibly powerful— one will reap what one sows. He who tied the knot must be the one to undo it. Buddhas and Bodhisattvas have great compassion and great powers, but you need to correct your attitude, be sincere and cultivate. Only then can negative karma be reversed naturally without even trying.

Proving we are right

Elder (Monk) Guang Qing

The path of Dharma practice has many differences from worldly paths. It is not about competing to see who is right or wrong. In the past, there were two disciples who were meditating.  One sat in the meditation posture very well. The other was leaning to one side and sitting crookedly. But the teacher hit the disciple who was sitting well with a rope.  

If it were modern practitioners, they would lose their temper and have all kinds of disturbing emotions.  However, that disciple went to his teacher feeling ashamed and asked for further guidance and advice.

Dharma practice is not about proving who is right or wrong.  You need this kind of kungfu (skill).  Even if you are right and others say you are wrong, you can accept it... an ordained practitioner should not be talking about right or wrong. You accept it if it is right; you accept it if it is wrong. When you develop such patience and endurance, you will slowly diminish your perception of self (ie, self-clinging).

Why experiential signs don't arise

HH Jigme Phuntsok Rinpoche

Some people practice daily but do not get any experiential signs.  This is not because the Triple Gems or Three Roots have no blessings. The main reason is that one’s karmic obscurations are too heavy and one is not diligent enough.  Some people do not put in much efforts in Dharma practice but go around saying many grand and empty words, telling all sorts of lies. Even if such people practice for many years, it will not be meaningful.

(Note: Telling lies degenerates the power of mantra)

Although it is not really possible to attain the common and uncommon siddhis and all the rest of the accomplishments within a short time during this degenerated age, the truth of interdependence (cause-and-effect) will never fail us. As long as we continuously strive on in practice, due to the undeceiving force of interdependence, the corresponding qualities and benefits will arise for us.  We will definitely get some signs of warmth through the practice.  This is not difficult to achieve at all.

(Note: “Signs of warmth” means that the practice is beginning to bear results.)

Of course, to attain the stage of Samantabhadra Buddha in this life is undoubtedly more difficult, however if we practice diligently, getting some signs of accomplishment is not difficult at all.

For instance, during this Grand Puja of Vidyadharas, there are tens of thousands sangha practicing together. I believe that as long as everyone visualize seriously and recite, all your wishes in this and future lives will be auspicious and free of any obstacles. Humans and non-humans will be respectful to you. 

I think such signs are not hard to obtain at all.  Some celestial beings who have accomplished the power of speech to a certain extent are already able to use mantras to curse others successfully.  If even such celestial beings with impure merits and qualities are able to say mantras that work, how could the Buddha’s mantras deceive sentient beings (and not work)?  Even if something impossible like water mixing with fire becomes possible, still it is impossible for the Buddha to deceive us. 

A normal mantra has various functions, but the mantras spoken by Buddha have unsurpassed qualities.  The various mantras spoken by Buddha in Sutra and Tantra arose from his wisdom mind and possess profound pure blessings. Similarly, the teachings of Buddha have unparallelled qualities.  It is not inferior and flawed like scriptures composed by a normal person or celestial beings.  

For instance, when we recite the Mani mantra single-mindedly and pray, even if we meet the greatest obstacle, it still can be resolved. But if one were reciting the mantra without serious visualization and without sufficient faith, such a recitation possesses merits but will not give rise to the signs of accomplishment quickly. 

When the causes are complete and present, the result will definitely arise.  It is absolutely impossible for mantras of the wisdom deities to be ineffective.  Although the practice texts of our pujas are not complicated, if you do not receive even the slightest response or sign, then it means that your visualization has been lacking or your recitation has not been diligent enough.  It means that your mind is caught up in distractions.  

There are some people who even fail to finish the required numbers of mantras during the puja.  Then you can only blame yourself (for not having any signs).  It doesn’t mean that the deity did not bestow blessings.  Therefore,  whenever we have pujas, everyone should recite diligently with strong faith.

Offering of Dharma is supreme

Bodhisattva Samantabhadra
(from the Avatamsaka Sutra)

Virtuous son, of all forms of offerings, the offering of Dharma is supreme.  This means, for instance, the offering of Dharma practice, the offering of benefitting sentient beings, the offering of accepting (or taking care of) sentient beings, the offering of bearing the sufferings of sentient beings on their behalf, the offering of assiduously training in virtues, the offering of not departing from a Bodhisattva's activities, the offering of not losing (the motivation of) Bodhichitta.  

Virtuous son, the previous offering (of material substances) is of infinite merits, yet it does not equal even one fraction of the merit gained from a single thought of offering Dharma. The merit of the former cannot equal even one hundredth or one thousandth of the merit of the latter. Moreover, the former cannot equal one fraction of a hundred-thousand koṭi-nayuta of the latter, nor can it compare by the minutest possible part in terms of time, calculation, number, analogy or fraction.

Why is this so? It is because all Tathāgatas revere the Dharma, and it is by practicing in accordance to Dharma teachings that Buddhas arise. If all Bodhisattvas offer Dharma, they accomplish offering to Tathāgatas, because cultivating in this way is the true offering.

Different worldviews in Buddhism are non-contradictory

Khenpo Tsultrim Lodro

When you attain the eighth Bodhisattva bhumi, you will see a world that is entirely different.  The Vimalakirti Sutra as well as many other scriptures state this.  If you really give rise to wisdom through your meditation, it will change the way you see the world utterly.  To reach this, you need the skills of the eighth bhumi...

Buddhist scriptures contain numerous descriptions about this world and the universe but these descriptions are not entirely consistent across different scriptures. For example, the Kalachakra Tantra describes the planet Earth differently from the Abhidharmakosha in the Hinayana.  Many Mahayana sutras also have varying descriptions of the universe.

More than a thousand years ago, many Buddhist masters in India began to investigate this question: why do the scriptures contain so many different descriptions of the universe?

Their conclusion was as follows. For instance, you want to describe a person. If you observed this person using the visible light spectrum, you would describe them one way; if you observed with infrared light, then you would need to describe the person differently.

For example, under infrared light, you might say, “Her hair is white and her skin is black.

The same principle applies to the universe described in the Buddhist scriptures. Different sentient beings, due to differences in karma and functioning of their senses, perceive the universe differently. Therefore, the universe can appear in many different aspects.

For example, we humans on Earth naturally perceive Earth as round—this is indisputable. However, other sentient beings may see Earth differently from us. This is precisely the greatness of Buddhist wisdom.

Buddhism takes into account the perspectives of different sentient beings. As a result, the scriptures contain many, many different descriptions. Buddhism teaches us not to cling to the notion that a particular appearance of the universe is the only true one, while all others are false.

The appearance of the universe—whether it’s the shape of Earth or the structure of the entire cosmos—is actually determined by the sensory perception and karma of sentient beings.

Thus, different beings and life-forms on different planets may reach different conclusions about the universe.  So, do not fixate on one form as the only truth.

In human history, only two groups have discovered this principle: one is the Buddha, and the other is western scientists.

This is because science discovered that observing the world using different types of light can yield different appearances. If you only considered the visible light spectrum, you might confidently say that human skin is only of these types of color and there is no other possibility.

But when you have more “eyes” that are able to see infrared and other wavelengths, then there is no single conclusion. You would only have to say that there are many possibilities. From one perspective, these are all true; from another perspective, they are all false. Thus, “true” and “false” are only relative. There is no absolute truth and there is no absolute falsehood.

This is precisely the greatness of Buddhist wisdom—it takes all possibilities into consideration.