Search This Blog

Saturday, August 1, 2026

Better not practice than practice wrongly

Dharma Master Jingjie

Externalists do not have the methods of Dharma to deal with thoughts. They use meditative concentration (samadhi) to extinguish thoughts; it is called the samadhi of non-thought. This suppresses thoughts like a stone pressing down on grass or like ice encasing a fish.

But why do they fall instead of ascending to liberation as they wish? This is because, after being reborn in the heavens in their next life, when they return to the human realm in the following life (the third life), their afflictions will become coarser and heavier than those of ordinary people. This is the result of suppressing afflictions at the causal stage.

You should take note of this! If you do not rely on Buddha's wisdom to transform your afflictions, but only use mantras and Amitabha’s name to suppress your thoughts, after suppressing them for a long time, when they rebound in your future lives, your afflictions may be even heavier. The Dharma uses the wisdom of Prajnaparamita and various skilful means to transform thoughts, but externalists rely entirely on brute force to suppress them.

In short, afflictions should not be merely suppressed because they will arise again. When the externalists lose their meditative concentration or exhaust their merits, the afflictions that surface will be heavier than those of ordinary people. Then they are very likely to create negative karma and fall into the lower realms. This is because your method of handling afflictions is wrong. This is the biggest blind spot of the externalists.

Thus, the consequence of not learning Dharma principles and investigating the scriptures is that, even though you are courageous and diligent, you may end up becoming a heavenly mara or externalist. This comes from not understanding the Buddha's skillful means…

Just as it is said in the Shurangama Sutra, our minds have many knots. The externalist's method is like pulling the rope from both ends, making the knot tighter. If this is the case, it would be better not to practice; because once they practice, they add another delusive thought on top of a delusion. Adding delusion to delusion is what makes an externalist.

Ordinary people have only one delusion, but externalists have two delusions—they have an additional wrong view. Buddhist disciples have the transmission of the Buddha; they know that this knot must be untied from the center, it should not be pulled from both ends…

This is the sorrow of the externalists: they very much want to improve, but they lack the right method, as a result, they make themselves worse off than if they hadn't practiced at all. Therefore, according to the Shurangama Sutra, practicing incorrectly is worse than not practicing. The Shurangama Sutra indeed has this meaning. When the past masters explained the Shurangama Sutra, they said, "One would rather go a thousand years without realisation than be possessed by the demon of wrong view for a single day"…

I met a Bhikshu in Taiwan who had ordained in his middle age, but he did not study Dharma theory. He told me that he didn't wish to study or read the texts. He was very earnest in bowing to the Buddha and reciting the sutras. I said, "Why don't you study the Dharma?" He replied, "Because I don't want to be a Dharma teacher."

Actually, studying the Dharma has nothing to do with being a Dharma teacher. If you want to practice, you must clearly recognize how to walk the path. That is to say, the principles of the Dharma are there to guide you, not for you to guide others. Of course, if you gain insights later on and wish to share them with others, that is doing your part according to the situation.

But the key point is, without the guidance of the Dharma, how would you know how to start dealing with the deluded thoughts you've accumulated since beginningless eons? This is the real point of learning Dharma.